Mr Clayton, my mind is now open to your trilogy of derivative Scarlet Pimpernel fiction. Or the second novel, at least (still can't stand pseudo-Marguerite in the first!)
My review from Librarything:
After being thoroughly Shocked and Appalled by everything about the first novel in C. Guy Clayton's Pimpernel trilogy, from concept to characters, I decided to actually pay good money for the second and third instalments, thereby compounding my disgust. However, I don't know if my rediscovered appreciation of the original Scarlet Pimpernel novels is merely diluted, or perhaps my imagination may have been opened to all forms of derivative fiction, but I wasn't all that offended by Clayton's perverse pastiche this time around.
( Wherein I betray Orczy )
- Location:The library
- Mood:
guilty
I am seriously hooked. I'm also about 7 years out of date, because I foolishly cocked a snook at the first novel and refused to read the books until, ooh, last month! I blame the harsh reviews on Amazon (I'm easily influenced). Yes, The Secret History of the Pink Carnation contains the most irritatingly bouncy heroine this side of Georgette Heyer's 1930s Regency romances - I renamed Amy Balcourt 'Tigger in a Dress' - and the occasional anachronism makes a guest appearance (sometimes on purpose, when Willig plays fast and loose with historical dates and personages to fit the plot), but more than anything, these novels are fun! And what's more - they source The Scarlet Pimpernel! (Yeah, you knew that was coming.) Sir Percy doesn't actually feature in any of the stories - more's the pity - but the flowery-titled spy in the first novel, who calls himself the Purple Gentian (the gag starts to droop after the first couple of books), is supposed to have joined the League ... and accidentally caused the death of Tony Dewhurst (I wish writers would leave the poor man alone!)
The central conceit of the series requires some suspension of disbelief - think Heyer, not Orczy. Modern day American grad student Eloise 'Mary Sue' Kelly is in London researching her dissertation on 'Aristocratic espionage during the wars with France: 1789-1815', or 'Why I love men in black masks'. The obvious starting point is the Scarlet Pimpernel, but Eloise receives a polite rebuff from the Blakeney estate and moves onto the family archives of the Purple Gentian - and the Pink Carnation, another as yet 'unmasked' spy. The male descendent of the Gentian line, Colin, is not impressed with Eloise's snooping, but his mother overrules him and lets Eloise at the family's conveniently extensive and in-depth collection of papers, kept in a trunk in a London apartment and behind the panelling at the country pile in Kent (supposedly next door to Blakeney Manor, which was in ... Surrey. Never mind.) There, Eloise leads the reader back two hundred years to 1803, where the journals and letters of the Gentian and Carnation become a sort of Regency romp to complement the chick lit of Eloise's first person narrative. The sequels follow the same pattern, with Eloise and Colin growing closer, and more floral secret heroes being unmasked, including the Carnation's nemesis, the Black Tulip (reminding me of the Black Fingernail in 'Carry On ... Don't Lose Your Head', which I have seen, unfortunately).
So far I'm at book 5, having temporarily skipped book 3, care of two library books and two very cheap used copies from Amazon marketplace. (I was lying to myself that I was only reading the series as 'an experiment', initially, but now I can't stop. Or find cheap copies of the next two books ANYWHERE! Catch up, Kindle - I'm willing to pay full price!) I heartily recommend Lauren Willig's novels, if you are the mood for vaguely historical fluff with a connection to The Scarlet Pimpernel, sort of Heyer writes Orczy. The original US covers are far better than the generic photo-art rebranding of the UK editions, though (see above).
- Location:The library
- Mood:
impressed - Music:Dedicated Follower of Fashion
- Location:The library
- Mood:
creative - Music:Where's the girl
My bookshelf of shame: the original novel (in various guises) and sequels
I meant to follow up my literary crush on Jane Austen's Emma with an honorary entry for The Scarlet Pimpernel by Baroness Orczy, and now seems a good time!
Oh, where to begin? The novels - of course - the films, the musical, or simply with Sir Percy Blakeney, the larger than life character who inspired fellow superheroes like Zorro and Batman, and is still going strong over 100 years later? The Baroness' rather gushing style of writing may have gone out of fashion, but the adventure - and the romance - are timeless.
( Storybook ending )
- Location:The library
- Mood:
nostalgic - Music:Vivez, Christine Andreas
I blame two fun blogs I found while illictly flicking round t'interwebnet at work: A Scarlet Pimpernel Blog (enthusiastic) and pimpernelobsessed (monumentally brilliant - and I'm not even sure how Tumblr works). Where were these blogs a couple of years ago, when my own manic love for the books/films/soundtrack was flagging? Why do I always seem to miss the boat with my passing fads?
For the moment, I'm just going to sit back and enjoy Leslie Howard as Sir Percy - 'Can't rise above anything with more than three sylllables, m'dear. Never could' - and the wonderfully exotic beauty of Merle Oberon as Marguerite.
- Location:The Daydream
- Mood:
nostalgic
And I still have no ambition to read the book.
Great film poster, though.
- Location:At home
- Mood:
apathetic
1. Favourite Austen heroine
Emma Woodhouse. She has it all – intelligence, looks, wealth – and doesn’t have to marry, but finds love with her best friend.
- Favourite Austen man
Mr Knightley. There may be a pattern developing here.
- Favourite Austen book
You can have three guesses, but one will no doubt suffice. Yep. Emma.
- Favourite quote from the books
‘The person, be it gentleman or lady, who has not pleasure in a good novel, must be intolerably stupid’ (Henry Tilney, Northanger Abbey)
- Favourite moment in the books
The end, but not in a snarky way! I’m not usually a sucker for Happy Ever Afters, but when Austen’s heroes and heroines finally get together, the result is always heart-warming. And Austen never overeggs the pudding, providing plenty of romantic potential for the imaginations of her readers.
- Favourite movie adaptation
Emma (2009), which I must have watched at least ten times on my iPod alone! But honourable mention goes to Pride and Prejudice (2005), which succeeded in bringing the characters to life for me where Colin Firth’s soggy shirt failed ten years earlier.
- Favourite Austen couple
Emma Woodhouse and George Knightley, bien sûr! I think these two would have the strongest marriage out of all Austen's couples.
- Least favourite couple
Fanny Price and Edmund Bertram *yawn* Process of elimination is not the best way to find a husband, Fanny, especially not when the last man standing is your cousin.
- Most hated foe of a heroine
Mrs Norris’ uppity treatment of Fanny Price in Mansfield Park. And I don’t even like Fanny Price!
- Most frustrating family member
I hate hypochondriacs like Mr Woodhouse, but Mary Musgrove of Persuasion is the whining attention seeker who aggravates most – and that’s just from watching the 1995 adaptation!
( And on. If you really want to know! )
- Location:At home
- Mood:
dorky
This year is the centenary of the 'unsinkable' Titanic, which hit an iceberg on the fourth night of her maiden voyage from Southampton to New York and sank, claiming the lives of over 1,500 passengers and crew. There are countless books and films on the topic, and even more rabid 'Titaniacs' in different historical camps who will always be fascinated by the fateful ship, but by far the best 'memorial' for me is Roy Baker's 1958 film version, A Night To Remember. Forget the big budgets and special effects of Hollywood. Don't bother with 'soap opera' specials set aboard the doomed liner. A Night to Remember, filmed in glorious black and white at Pinewood Studios, has it all: historical ambience, heartwrenching emotion, comic relief and understated dignity. Who needs hokey romances or cliched melodrama to engage the audience? The Titanic should be the story, not merely the setting.
( 'But she can't sink! She's unsinkable!' )
- Location:The library
- Mood:
impressed
First book of the year: George Knightley Esquire: Charity Envieth Not by Barbara Cornthwaite
Last book of the year: Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke
Favourite book (not counting re-reads): George Knightley Esquire: Lend Me Leave by Barbara Cornthwaite
Most spectacular waste of money: A toss-up between The Queen's Dollmaker by Christine Trent (which I did manage to finish) or The Other Boleyn Girl by Philippa Gregory (which I didn't, because life is too short). Both of which I purchased on Kindle in haste and repented at leisure.
Best series of the year: Vampire Academy by Richelle Mead. YA books about teenage vampires - but I was totally hooked!
( E-readers and bloodsuckers )
- Location:The library
- Mood:
accomplished
Persuasion by Jane Austen
Persuasion is the Austen pick of the pops: the novel which all the long-time/serious/high-brow 'Janeites' seem to love and cherish and
Perhaps, when I am older (another theory), my taste in Austen will reach the zenith of appreciation, and I will finish Persuasion. After all, I liked the adaptation (not the one with the fish kiss), and I can read stories 'based on' Persuasion, like Juliet Archer's modernisation Persuade Me (although I didn't really like that one, either), but the actual text itself still bores me silly. Sorry, Janeites, I'm yet to be persuaded!
- Location:The library